Illustrative example

A report result that keeps evidence, conclusion, and unknown facts separate.

This example uses a fictional website and source snapshot. It shows the customer review structure without a claim about a real user or result.

Illustrative visitor input

Visitor report

Profile save fails when the time zone is blank

Problem · Example Site · Profile settings

I selected Save on my profile, but the page showed an error and kept the old details.

Safe browser evidence

EV-001

Failed request metadata

POST /api/profile → 500 in 412 ms

No query values, headers, or bodies.

EV-002

Form-field metadata

time-zone · present: false · size: 0

No form value.

Source evidence

EV-003

Example source snapshot 4f7a2c1

src/routes/profile.ts:118–124

const zone = profile.timeZone.trim();
return saveProfile({ ...profile, timeZone: zone });

The cited branch uses the field before an absent-value check.

Evidence assessment

Conclusion

The save path likely does not handle an absent time-zone field.

Likely

The failed request, missing field metadata, and cited source branch form a related evidence chain.

Limit: The example does not prove how many profiles have this state or whether every request used the same release.

Unknown facts

  • The number of affected profiles. The approved evidence contains one report, not an aggregate count.
  • The complete release distribution. The example identifies one source snapshot only.

Recommended action

Handle an absent time-zone value before the save path uses it.

  1. Add a null-safe branch.
  2. Add a focused regression test for an absent time zone.
  3. Use the normal human review and release process.

Low risk Human approval is required.

Draft response

Thank you for the report. We found a likely issue in the active profile save path. The website owner will review the recommended change before release.

The owner can edit and copy this draft. IssueProbe does not send it.